
The cheap car problem
Why the cheapest car on any lot is sometimes the expensive one
There is a car on this lot at $8,650 and a car at $30,500. The interesting thing about that range is not the difference in the cars. It is the difference in what happens after you buy them.
The cost that is not on the sticker
A car over a hundred thousand miles comes with no statutory warranty, which is a real cost even if nothing goes wrong, because it is the difference between a repair being somebody else's problem for thirty days and it being yours from the first mile.
Then there is the arithmetic nobody does at the desk. A set of tyres is several hundred dollars. A set of discs and pads all round is several hundred more. A timing belt on an engine that has one is most of a thousand. On a car at eight thousand dollars, one of those is more than a tenth of what you paid.
The question worth asking instead
This is not an argument for the expensive car. It is an argument for asking a different question: not what does it cost, but what does it cost to run it for two years. Sometimes the cheap car wins that comfortably — a high-mileage car with a fresh belt, new tyres and a full history often does.
What loses it every time is a cheap car with no history, because then none of those questions has an answer and every one of them is a coin toss at your expense.
The short version. Add the cost of the tyres, the brakes and any belt that is due to the asking price, and then compare the cars. It changes the ranking more often than not.
Where this connects on the site
The New York warranty, banded by mileage
What a car over a hundred thousand miles loses that the sticker price does not show.
Our prices
Every price on the lot today, and where each figure actually comes from.
Have a look at what is on the lot
Every car in stock, with its price, its mileage and the warranty band that mileage puts it in. Filter it down to what you can actually spend, and book 45 minutes with the one you want to drive.